Seth Godin Does It All Wrong – Maybe You Should Too

Very few blogs are really good. With that established, the logical question is what makes a blog really good? Why is it that so many people read Seth Godin in spite of the fact that he doesn’t really follow most conventional wisdom about blogging and writes rather short posts? I believe it’s because he and others like him do something effectively that most blogs don’t do – they engage their readers.
You might have fallen into the trap of writing articles for the traffic, the entertainment value, or merely to fill another quota. But what if you only wrote posts that were engaging? How would it affect your readership over time?
Writing potent, powerful, engaging articles requires us to face some harsh criteria by asking three vital questions…
Am I Stimulating the Intellect? (Do I Make You Think?)
When it comes to the usability and navigation of your site, dont’ make people think. But when it comes to your content making people wrestle with concepts is the goal. Think of it this way – would your last article cause me to pause on my sprint through my feed reader? I’ll give you a hint – you can make me think starting with the title.
Am I Engaging the Emotions? (Do I Make You Feel?)
Human emotions are powerful – enough so to influence us to make destructive or life-altering choices at times. Human emotions are also like channels through which people establish a connection with us. This is why writing from the gut can be so valuable. People identify with us on the basis of an emotion.
Your article can frighten, encourage, sadden, excite, and even enrage. When it does, people will interact with it, spread it, and remember it. Further, they’ll remember that you evoked that emotion and they may just come back for more.
Am I Influencing the Will? (Do I Make You Change?)
In common marketing terminology this is the “call to action,” and this may actually need to be the starting place for our article writing. Before you get the first paragraph out, decide what you’re going to call your readers to do at the end.
Buy. Give. Comment. Share. Subscribe. Repent. Re-paint. Re-evaluate. Depending on the niche, you may want to influence your readers to do any number of things. Usually, the first two questions are pre-requisite to the third simply because people don’t normally make decisions unless they feel the need to do so based on the information they’ve received.
If we aren’t fulfilling these requirements with a large majority of our posts, we’ll never recruit a community of loyalists. This is what humanity is made of – we think, we feel, and we make decisions. Everything else is fluff. Now, go write an article that makes me think, feel, and do.
Photo Credit: marcobellucci


I think that you’re exactly right. People focus on creating link bate and trying to keep up with the latest widgets and plugins and they forget all about the basics.
I recently posted an article at my site that discussed three powerful laws for getting and keeping visitors. In it I stated that I believe that most people visit websites for a combination of these three reason: education, entertainment, and engagement.
Wikipedia is popular because it educates and informs. YouTube is popular because it entertains. Facebook is popular because it allows engagement.
I believe that we should be striving to accomplish all three of these at our blogs.
Sorry for the long comment.
I read that article you wrote – very nice! Wanted to give everyone a link to it – Getting and Keeping Visitors. Good stuff!
Thanks man. I really appreciate that. I certainly wasn’t trying to be self-serving in my comments but sure do appreciate that link. You’re the best. Keep up the awesome content here.
Brandon! Well done! I loved this post you came up with some very profound points. Way to go.
Thanks Megan!
I think you’re absolutely right, the more experience I gain, the more I realize it’s less about having tons of content and more about being useful in some way to your readers. Sometimes quick tip or paragraphs is all that is needed to be helpful and clear. Great article Brandon!
Thanks Drew – spot on! I think it’s why we love single line quotes so much – they stick with us.
I think Seth Godin is successful in part BECAUSE his posts are so brief, rather than in spite of it. Even his books are fairly short for the most part. He probably realizes that his audience doesn’t have a lot time time to spend reading his blog so he makes them short and to the point.
You’re right, Curtis. Amazingly, he charges more for short books the most do for long books, and I’ve bought several.
I think most people tune into people like Seth, just to see what he is saying. Most people gloss over blogs, just to get an idea what their competitors are saying or doing, or to get a fill of whats out there and whats been talked about. Everyone doesn’t want to read long post. But, I have notice that no one makes commits on his blog either! So he may have a high traffic, but his audiences are not engaging with each other. Great Post!
Mosotomoss, there are no comments on Seth’s blog because he has them turned off. He engages in other ways. If you email him, he’ll answer you personally (usually in a few hours). I often wonder how he manages to do it, since he must have a huge volume of e-mail messages. And, of course, there’s also Triiibes.com.
This post is spot on. Totally agree, Seth has got the formula right. However, I have discovered that he infuriates a lot of people in the Head Hunting world – particularly when he advises talented people to forget the resume and the job hunting – go set up your own business. Not hard to see why they feel threatened.